1

I can see that another patent has cited my (then pending) patent under the References Cited section, with a * indicating that the citation was added by the examiner.

Where can I find out if/how this patent has used my method or how do the inventors describe my method? I can only see my patent in their references, but unlike publications, I don't see a sentence that actually refers to my work.

Is it common to just have a list of references without actually referring to them in the document? If I can't necessarily find whether they used my work, what is the correct way of describing this citation? Is it correct to say they "used" my work?

1 Answer 1

2

As part of filing a patent application, you are obligated to cite any prior art you know to be relevant to your invention. Citing a patent doesn't mean you are referencing it specifically in the specification. Thus, I don't think you are going to find some pointer to some specific reference in the patent document's text outside of the cited patents section. As you noted, the patent examiner also does a prior art search and may cite that prior art they deem to be relevant.

To answer your questions specifically.

Is it common to just have a list of references without actually referring to them in the document?

Yes, I believe so. I think it is considered safer to cite known patents that are even remotely relevant rather than not doing so.

If I can't necessarily find whether they used my work, what is the correct way of describing this citation?

It's just a citation. Your patent might simply be in the same field as the patent citing it or using a similar technology in a different field.

Is it correct to say they "used" my work?

No it isn't correct. They are simply citing your patent as relevant. They may or may not describe that relevance in the specification and if they do it may just be to explain why their invention is different.

Just to be clear, I am not an attorney, simply someone with several patents.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .